Email Our Firm

Creating Substitute Construction Contracts

Earlier this week we shed some light on the consequences of cancelling construction contracts. As we noted, things can change in an instant in the construction business, causing us to reconsider the contracts we signed. Fortunately, those changes don't always necessarily lead to contract cancellation.

In certain circumstances, a contract substitute can replace an existing contract in order to account for circumstances we maybe didn't previously consider.

Of course, you can't just force a substitute contract on another party. Everyone must agree the substitute is meant to replace the existing contract. It seems simple, but the law often requires more than just a handshake agreement.

An Oregon Court of Appeals case from last year addressed this very issue. In Rucker v. Rucker, a plaintiff demanded payment based on a first contract, while the defendant insisted a substitute contract changed the payment amount. The Court held that a substitute contract is formed if the intent to substitute the new contract for the existing contract is "clearly shown."

Though the Court didn't set a hard and fast rule for when intent is clearly shown, it noted the parties in that case memorialized their new agreement in writing, as well as their intentions to abide by the new agreement. Additionally, the new contract had terms that rejected claims arising from the prior contract. 

Although the court's ruling applies beyond the construction context, you can imagine how important it is to an industry that operates mostly by handshake agreements. You should always consult a construction law attorney to help you evaluate the effectiveness of your construction contracts, especially when their terms change.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Client Testimonials

  1. “Your business model is such a fresh approach to the way legal services are typically delivered.”

    President, Manufacturing
  2. “Phil will help you understand the process you are going through, and is very passionate about your needs and situation.”

  3. “Phil, responded to my numerous questions promptly and completely. Very reasonable rates, no overbilling. Kept me informed of progress.”

  4. “Ben legally clarified the language in my contracts without turning them into super verbose mumbo-jumbo.”

    Kevin L.
  5. “Everyone, that I've interacted with is professional, knowledgeable, forthcoming with information and educating and caring.”

    Alanna C.

425 NW 10th Avenue
Suite 200
Portland, OR 97209

Toll Free: 866-280-7562
Phone: 360-258-1268
Fax: 503-417-4250
Map & Directions